So I've been having sex for 3 years with the same guy. Last night though, I bled! It wasn't period blood, it was blood blood. He's not the biggest, but we usually go pretty intensely and I've never bled before! He did finger me, but his nails are super short so I know he didn't cut me. I feel stupid for asking this, but could he finally have broken my hymen after that long?!? We did try a new position and it hurt a LOT but then it felt SO good after! Anyone have any ideas?