Guy who cheated or the nice guy 🤔

So how can I put this.....I like two guys and I know I can't keep leading them on but idk who to pick..... Guy #1 (he cheats) I liked him since the beginning of the school year but he had a girlfriend (girl #1) but then he changed of her with girl #2 and him and her lasted longer then the first one but then one stupid drunk night he cheated of her with me!! And I felt so bad so I stayed away from him and his girlfriend and plus I would talk to his girlfriend sometime then later they broke up and they both cheated on each other so me and guy #1 got closer and he says he likes me but isn't ready for a relationship again but yet we have sex and he called me princess so it's like we're dating but it's a secret/: now about guy #2 (the nice guy) he's so sweet to me he hasn't tried anything on me and when guy#1 was still with he's girlfriend me and guy#2 started to talk and he's just fun to be around and I know he won't hurt me but I'm pretty sure he never had sex before and well I just don't know who to pick someone help