UPDATE: If you're just going to be rude or judgemental please dont even bother commenting on my post. Im looking for GENUINE suggestions. Not critisism. Thank you in advance.

SLIGHT TMI WARNING!

Ladies! I have a HUGE dilemma!!! So me and my boyfriend are VERY sexually active. Like at least twice a day when we're together all day. However, whenever we use condoms neither of us feel almost anything. We can't use thin or lamb skin because personally, I'm pretty tight and he's relatively girthy. So they always break. I'm not on the pill (yet, running through some tests with my doctor first due to previous health problems.) and the pullout method has been working great for us so far but I'm a hypochondriac and if my cycle is one day late I freak. Basically my question is do you ladies have any suggestions for good brands of condoms? What works for you?