Any Real Estate Subject matter experts here?

Ms.
If you were buying a house and had to choose between 2 houses built by same company, and located on the same street, which would you choose.
House 1- 10yrs old, 1700sqft, 3bd/2.5bath, has many upgraded options (fireplace, en suite master bathroom which has jacuzzi bath and a separate shower with glass door, washer/dryer included and has a patio) , basement is unfinished. Approximate $10k to finish basement , Closing cost paid for by seller( $11k), and purchase price is 320k.
House 2- is a brand new construction, 3bd/3.5bath, 2300sqft, hardwood flooring, finished basement and the cost of upgrades costs $10k, they give you $5k to pay part of your $11k closing cost, and house purchase price is $335k. 
Which would you choose? 

Vote below to see results!