Too Much Makeup?

Do I wear too much eye makeup? The other day, a table I was serving told my manager to tell me that I should tone down on the makeup a little bit and one time, a male co-worker called me a raccoon and suggested that I watch the way I put it on because guy's think women who wear a lot of makeup are trashy. Since then, I'm always self-conscious about my eye makeup and making sure it's even.