Yes! My daughter was really hard to ween off of it. I tried everything then when she was almost 3 I cut every single one of them around the house and at first she was confused and still tried to keep it in her mouth or chew on it somewhere but eventually she just wanted to hold it while she fell asleep and then didn't need them at all and just totally forgot about them. Wish I did it sooner but I didn't even think of it. I recommend to all parents I meet you have a problem with getting them off of it (I work with parents and young children)