Honest Opinions. Starry Night Recreation.

kyla • 🌞🌿🌈🌻🌊🍯

So, as a gift for my dad for Christmas I wanted to do my own little recreation of Starry Night. It’s his favorite painting and he recently moved into a new house (6 hours away from me) so I thought it would kind of be a housewarming gift as well as a Christmas present. Anyway, I usually like how my paintings turn out but I just feel like I can’t get this one right. These are my two attempts. Do they look decent? Which one do you guys like best? What could I go to improve? Please comment!