Big Mistake

this story involves two guys. Guy 1 and guy 2. me and guy 1 have been friends for three years. He is always nice to me and has a crush on me. He helps me with hw and problems I have. Guy 2 is known for being a fuck boy. I met him last summer and we have been talking. I saw the good in him instead of seeing the bad. He came over and nothing happened the first time we kissed awkwardly. The second time we made out and it was fine he didn't try anything he just kept his hands on my back and hips. The third time is where we hit the problem. This guy (guy 2) is friends with a guy in my class and I am too. so the guy that has come over before came over and I had my friend their and he brought his. They went downstairs while we were upstairs. we started making out and he grabbed my butt and was rubbing my stuff over my pants. I didn't mind but I didn't want to do anything else. He put his hand down my pants and I said not while their here (referring to mine and his friend). He stopped and pulled his hand out. He didn't touch my vagina just the top of it. After he left he went to a basketball game with my guy friend thats in my class. There he told this guy that he fingered me and my friend walked in on it. The guy in my class texted my best friend that was there and said that he told him that. She immediately texted me and told me at first I was making fun of it saying the rumors of me being a lesbian would go away but after we stopped texting reality hit. I started freaking out realizing this could be spread. I texted my best guy friend and told him because none of my friends had time for me even though I told them it was an emergency. He made me laugh and made me feel better. I like him now too. I feel like I'm in too deep with the other guy. Tomorrow at school is what I fear the most. I have no idea what to do about liking this guy and the rumors that could be spread.