Which name is more popular?

Question

We like both names, but it seems Scarlett is very popular right now, and I would prefer less popular names.

Answer

Aubree is my ten year olds name. She’s never had another Aubree in her school

Answer

Naming my daughter Aubree.

Answer

Do you live in the US? In 2016, Scarlett was the 18th most popular name given to baby girls. Aubree was 84th -- but Aubrey was 25th most popular. So she might have a classmate that pronounces her name the same but spells it differently. Hard to tell from these rankings which name is more popular, because of the alternate spellings. 
So ignoring popularity ranking and looking instead at the number of girls given each name in 2016... the name Scarlett / Scarlet was given to a total of 8542 babies (7680 + 862). The name Aubree / Aubrey was given to 9897 babies (3390 + 6507). 
So if you only care about spelling, Aubree is less popular than Scarlett. But if you care about the name in general and it's multiple spellings (that is, her odds of needing to use a last initial at school, or whatever) then Scarlett is less popular than Aubree/Aubrey. But not by much. 
I think you're fine either way. Fewer kids are given each name nowadays than when we were kids, so today there are almost never situations like my fourth grade class, with three Ashleys.

Which name is more popular?

Let's Glow!

The Top Baby Tracker App: Embrace New Beginnings with Tender Care

The Top Fertility Tracker App: Your Path to Achieving Pregnancy

The Top Pregnancy App: Nurturing Your Journey to Motherhood

The Top Period Tracker for Empowering Your Menstrual Health Journey