Painful

So last night I had sex for the second time EVER. I wanted it to be amazing because I am absolutely in love with my boyfriend. But it hurt. BAD. I actually asked him to stop because I couldn’t physically stop myself from crying. He was super understanding and hugged me and told me that everything is okay. But I’m still worried. I don’t think it should hurt that horribly. It hurt like this the first time too. And on top of that, I think it freaked him out too and I just don’t want things to become weird between us. Any helpful tips or info?