Girl names that go well with Caleb?

Emily • Mama to 👦🏼👧🏼, expecting 👶🏻.
We are having a little girl in November!! Now we just have to choose a name. Our two-year-old is Caleb Jerome, so are looking for names that go well with his. I always try to think of how we'd sign a card: "Mike, Emily, Caleb, and ____." I am finding that I tend to like vintagey girls names and ones that end in ie/y (or at least have a nickname like that). A few favorites are Penelope (Penny), Zoe, and Ruby, but we're not set on anything yet. Please list suggestions!!! Thanks :)