A painting? A gift card? A painted personal “Color Me Mine” ceramic piece? A ticket to a show? A heartfelt card? A teddy bear?? Lol

This is my first time ever dating anyone seriously and ever spending valentines day with a man i love. Im 19 and hes 23. He is very open minded and kind. I want to do something sweet for him but im not sure. Hes more extroverted and im introverted but he has more of a “goody” side while ive had my share of “wild days”. Im just not sure what do do😩😩

Any ideas?