What do I do????

I have a guy friend I’ve known forever. He’s always had a crush on me. He treats me VERY well. It’s always what I want to do and where I want to go. If my feet hurt he offers to rub them. Even if I asked him to go get his toes painted pink with me I’m 100% he’d do it. I KNOW he’s never cheat on me. Hurt me. Or do me wrong. BUTTTTTTT I’m not attracted to him. I see him only as a funny loving guy friend. I’ve dated the hot sexy guys before and they would just cheat on me or ignore me all the time or hit me. Should I give this poor guy a chance and date him?????? I’ve known him since middle school we’re now 20