Menstrual cup is super messy? Anyone else?

So I finally got a menstrual cup and I love it :D been using it for the past 3~ periods. And I've definitely gotten the hang of it. But whenever I take it out in the bathroom. I dump it in the toilet like you're supposed to, wipe it off a little with some toilet paper. Ans when I reinsert it, i get blood all over my hands, no matter how light my period is. Am i doing something wrong here? Or is this normal? Im fine with it, but just want to know if theres a more clean way to do this. If not then whatever. Thanks!!!!