No connection?

I seriously want to cry while writing this, and it’s been on my mind a ton lately. I’ve been dating this guy since January, so not too long. But we talked since November, and dated for a bit right before we graduated. He’s the nicest and purest guy in the world, I feel lucky that he even likes me. However, ever since the beginning, I just haven’t felt that click. I know the relationship is young, but if I remember back to my past relationships, it seems like we clicked by now. It’s sometimes awkward, I don’t know what to say, and in general I just don’t think we’re connected. It’s so weird because I want to be with him, I want things to work. My family loves him, he’s super nice and would do anything for me. I’m moving to be with him in August, and I’m so nervous. Mostly because I feel so distant, I don’t know how I’ll make it with it just being him and I. We laid in bed yesterday and I just kept thinking how weird it felt. We used to call and it’s seriously like we had nothing to talk about. Our friend groups are different, it doesn’t seem like we have common ground. Everyone loves him, people connect with him far better than I do. I don’t get it...Is it normal to feel this way? How do I make it so we’re connected? I want it to work out, I just genuinely don’t understand why it isn’t natural. Should it be?