PLEASE I NEED HELP!!! REAAAD PLEASE:

I’m meeting my long distance boyfriend of two & a half years for the first time, he’s coming for my senior prom & I’m scared that the flights I keep finding the cheapest ($400-$488) are going to end up horribly..& they’re all from MyHolidays.com, which I’ve heard a few bad reviews from and idk if I should be worried. I’m helping my boyfriend find flights, but it’s my first time doing this.. & I was really excited tillI saw some of the reviews.. tho most are good, the bad ones are scaring me a bit.. can someone please help me & let me know if this website is to be trusted..? Please..? I just want to meet my boyfriend..