First time trying anal...

My boyfriend and I are sex lovers. We are always do all kinds of positions (vaginal) only. So he decided to spice things up by trying anal. I was so nervous to do it, but I gave in. we both started to put vaseline on ourselves. My butt & his private.. after he began to try to ease the tip in. I didn’t feel anything until all of sudden this excruciating pain poked me viciously and it made me make a low scream. & I quickly moved from our anal position. He asked me if i was okay and suggested we never try it again. Overall anal was awful for me. #imgoodonit

do yall enjoy anal?