Which weight looks more ideal for my body?

Question

Or

Answer

You look wonderful as both, what do you feel more comfortable as? What gives you more confidence and makes you happier?

Answer

As someone who is naturally very thin I definitely think you look better in the top pics. I wish I looked as good as that! There's nothing sexy about my chicken legs, tooth pick arms and pancake butt!

Answer

i know that youre not naturally anorexic looking so higher weight. i bet you feel more free, more energetic, have more fun, hangout and go out more, live your life more at a higher weight and have less fear. gain that weight and be proud of how far you come and that u can say u are healthy and living life. promise u its worth it, been there done that and relapsed 3x but im finally a year without relapse, and i promise its worth it in the end even if some days u do not feel great!

Answer

Alright I may as well come out with the truth seeing as how I received many responses and I was actually shocked at the results: 
I am 5 ‘3 
In the very first pic, my highest weight, I was 107 pounds. That gave me a BMI of 18.95. 
The second “high weight” pic I am not entirely sure but am a bit less than in the first pic I know that. 
I actually forget what pics I or for the lower weights now but one of them is me at my current weight: 90 pounds and a BMI of 16.