First time using a butt plug - embarrassing 🙇🏼‍♀️

Lol sooo my boyfriend and I ordered a butt plug from Spencer’s. It’s a smaller one that vibrates right... so we decided to use it last night. First, that thing looks small but it didn’t feel small going in! Once we pushed it in, it kept wanting to come out, so my boyfriend was pushing it in a little further. I told him to hold the loop while he was doing me from the back, so it didn’t slip. Well he was going pretty hard back there, and then he came but kept going. When he finally calms down, he decides to check on the butt plug and the loop was nowhere to be found. So that made him freak out and with no warning, he sticks his entire finger in my butthole and finally barely touches the loop and manages to pull it out. 😂🤦🏼‍♀️ it hurt! So after seeing horror stories on here about people pooping on their boyfriends dicks, I grabbed the butt plug and went to the bathroom to wash it off before he turned on the lights and what do ya know? There were pieces of poop on it... I washed it before he came in, then we both looked at each other and started laughing. He said “if I couldn’t get that out, I was gonna tell you you were just gonna have to just push” and I was like “yeah if it didn’t come out I was gonna push because there’s no way I’m going to the ER and sitting in the waiting room while it vibrates on the chair” 😂😂🤦🏼‍♀️