Gift for Physical anniversary?

So very long story short, we've been together over two years. But a year and a half of that was spent as an online relationship. Tomorrow marks the day of it being exactly a year of us being physically together.
We're going to celebrate... But gifts? Should I get a gift? We didn't talk about that one and its too late now to ask (heh... Are we getting each other gifts? Especially if he has gotten me something already..) 
So what do you think? I want to get him a nice card, maybe his favorite candy, something lime that. 
But should I go nicer than that? Should I get him a fun gadget? Or something really meaningful like an engraved something or something scrapbook like? 
Thoughts please! Need to choose this morning xD cus i need whatever it ends up being for tomorrow