Girl names! Help!

My husband and I are expecting our second(find out gender next month). We have Landon James Sims picked for a boy, but we have trouble with girl names. I like names that are unique or at least not used as often, but he thinks a unique name will be made fun of. He specifically doesn't want her to be the only one in her class with the name🙃. We picked Madelyn Lydia for our 1st. I like names like layla, lena, freya, elise. Suggestions for a compromise please?!?!