Not sexually attracted to him but attracted to everything else about him ...

Whenever I talk to this guy, like texting and stuff I feel like I really like him and I wanna be with him and hang out with him. But when I’m with him, it’s fun but I just don’t feel sexually attracted to him. We had sex and the sex was pretty good but like idk when I look at him I just don’t feel attracted to him physically. And I feel SOOOOOOO SHALLOW!! How a guy looks has never been an issue. I’ve dated guys who were really skinny, muscular and had a dad bod so I know I’m not that shallow. Dated guys with and without facial hair. Different hair colours and types of hair (sounds like I’ve gotten around a lot but I haven’t, each guy was just very different).

Should I keep hanging out with him and see if the attraction forms? I really like literally everything else. Kinda would just wanna be his best friend not his girlfriend but I think it’s too late for that now ...