To TTC or not to TTC

Hubby and I have decided to try for baby #3!!

The first 2 were immediate (so immediate that we joke about how we conceived my daughter just talking about it). Although I don't necessarily expect that to be the case with #3, I'm aware it's a real possibility for us. Part of me wants to go out and buy a bunch of ovulation and pregnancy tests, but part of me is superstitious and feeling like I should stick to what has worked in the past (aka no tracking, no thinking, just good ol' fashion baby making...) and I can't even bring myself to buy the cheaper test strips because I got both my prior positives on a First Response pink dye test. I literally chicken out every time I go to buy ovulation tests or a different brand of pregnancy tests because I feel like it will ruin my chances 🤦🏻‍♀️

Anyone else feel painfully committed to what has worked in the past?