I’m so confused 🙈🙈

Alana

So there was this new stock boy at the department store across from mine and we started off flirting and I was so attracted to him and always excited to see him I mean when I first saw him I was so turned on by his salt and pepper hair and his tattooed toned arms😍😍 he would stare long and hard at me and I would do the same and I’d wave at him and smile and he’d wink at me or smile and wave back. Now he’s always popping into my job talking to my coworkers and asking me what time I was on lunch and I think he was going to ask me for my phone number but a customer walked in and everytime im with a customer when he pops in and I catch him looking at me . Now we’re making small talk and to me the magic is gone and idk if I like him as much anymore or even if I want to date him. I ask my manager if he thinks he’s cute and he said yes he’s very handsome and that him liking me is a good thing and he said yes and I should like him back and lol that I better find that magic and not think so much about it. Am I weird ? Should I give him my phone number ? Should I date him ? Why am I like this ? He’s so sweet and I was initially attracted to him and I like looking at him and his grey hair and nice arms lol is this normal or am I just weird lol. What should I do ?