Who is Mr Right?!

Gabby • Joshua 1:9 ❤️
So I've gotten myself into a little pickle with this new church I am attending. My parents have befriended, and are now best friends with a South African family (my dad is also South African). This family is so perfect and they are all so good looking with perfect tanned skins. Their son (let's call him A) is two years older than me and we are getting pretty close. We also share a mutual best friend (let's call her C) who I would do anything for. However C's boyfriend has a nefew two years older than me (let's call him B) who is also very good looking and I've been getting to know him a lot lately and C's whole family plus her boyfriends family are trying to set me up with B. However A's family is trying to set me up with A. I like both boys but I can't choose :/ here's a summary of both boys:
A:
Hot
Taller
Great singer
Smart
South African
Really chilled out
Same music taste as me 
Tends to ignore his friends when other girls are around
Is a player sometimes 
B:
Hot
Muscly
Same height as me
Intelligent 
Fun
Great sense of humour
Sweet <3
Can't make up his mind when his ex comes into the equation:/ 
Help please? x