Ovulation/OPK confusion

Lainey • Due with Baby #1 Nov. 2016!
So on Day 10 of my cycle I started testing with Clear Blue Easy (the one where it's either just "surge" or "no surge." Saturday morning I tested with that and came up negative. That day I bought the other Clear Blue Easy OPK - the one that will give you low, high, or peak fertility. I tested the same night with that test and came up with peak fertility. The next morning I tested with the first OPK again and it came up no surge.
We Bd'ed first thing Sunday morning and also on Thursday. I'm wondering why the two tests came up different in such a short time period and if I missed my window (i don't know which test was right!).
Any thoughts?