Baby girl name thoughts.

Kara • Mother to a my little man 6/19/14 due with baby 2 4/21/16
My husband and I are having a hard time agreeing on a name for our baby girl. April will be here before we know it! He is Italian so I want her name to be Italian. Our sons name is Luciano. I like unique names that aren't common. We are thinking...
Filomena Elisa. Pretty much the only one we agree on... A lot of people say it's "too old" and reminds them of an "old lady"  
Thoughts?