Older, different names

R • Wed, Mar 30

I'm really struggling. I love my first son's name (Henry). I'm looking for another name I love just as much. We like William and Ben, but they are both so popular. We also like Theodore. Does anyone have any older names they recommend that are less popular?

I looked through the top 3000 names in 2014 and the top 200 in 1880 and 1910. Nothing appealed to me. :(