which hospital to choose!?

Emily
Okay so my SO and I got to talking about hospitals today. We are 5wk 5 days today and I hadn't made our first appt yet. For our first 3 miscarriages we went to the same medical group and didn't have the greatest experiences. After we found out about our 3rd miscarriage we went to a different hospital to get another opinion. I LOVED it there and the doctor was amazing. I was so excited about going back to her but I called today just to find out that she is no longer there! :( super bummed! And I got to thinking today too and someone please give advice as to wether this is dumb or not...
I kinda wanted to go back to hospital #1 because I was hoping that my dr might be there.. BUT 
My SO also has a 3 year old girl whom he had at the second hospital with her mom. The more I think about it I kinda don't want to driver there only because I want our experience of bringing a baby into this world to be completely different then his daughters birth with her mom. 
Now I do think this might be the hormones talking but when your SO says things like "oh yes we did that with baby there" and "I remember we did that there".. it kinda bothers me because I want a new experience for the both of us. 
Someone please tell me I'm not crazy! I also know how dumb it sounds. I tried to talk to my SO about why I would want to try the first obgyn again and apparently didn't explain it right because he straight hung up on me.