HELP ME PLZ

Two guys like me IDK why but they do. One is like a foot shorter than me he is weird with me like I can complement his ass and he won't think I'm nasty I can be myself around him we dated a while ago but broke up cuz of him being insecure so there's that like I don't know if we will last I still have feelings and I get depressed when he talks to other girls. Then there is guy2 he is like a 5 out of ten he is so funny he is strong and willing to do whatever he can to get me I don't know if I like him that much we talked this summer and I told him I liked him And he told me he likes me then he tells me he has a girlfriend they broke up and now he likes me he asked me to the dance so I said maybe I asked guy1 if he would go with me he said no so I said yes to guy2 we had lots of fun we always do when we are together he checks in on me he texts me he smiles at me when I talk but he dated my best friend of course she told me to date him and it was like in second grade all my friends will think I'm weird but idc he also dated my other friend so I asked her if she still like him and she said IDK. WHO SHOULD I CHOSE?