Is it possible to "pop your cherry" twice?

So iv been sexually active since I was 16 and I'm 20 now but me and my bf have had sex multiple times and today we were just fooling around and he was fingering me and after a while we looked down and there was a lot of blood, and I knew it wasn't period blood cuz you can tell the difference so I'm just dumbfounded because my cherry was popped a while ago and that's what looked like what happened