Should I give him another chance?!?

So last year a met a guy on tinder, and we hooked up for four months, but he cut it off because I asked what we were and he just wanted to fuck. I got really mad at him for wasting my time and we stopped talking. Fast forward now, I've been hooking up with a new guy, and we like each other although we aren't official and we see each other occasionally.. but this morning the old guy messaged me and apologized and said he missed me.. and he wants to take me to the movies. Not sure if he's worth taking back, as he told me that he could find another girl with a 'big booty' .. but I do like this new guy although we have busy schedules...

But not sure if I should just go out once with the old guy... help?!?