Choosing a Dr

I'm having a dilemma and need some advice, but due to the early stage of pregnancy (4 weeks) I don't want to ask people I know. Our first is 16 months old and we just found out we are expecting #2! Called the dr who delivered #1 today, and he is no longer delivering. I was SUPER bummed because we loved him. Called another good dr in town and her OB schedule is booked for May '18. So I have two other options in town. One is a dr who has a lot of experience, but I was told by a nurse a while ago not to go to him. The other option is a very new dr to town and not sure how much delivering experience he has. My first pregnancy and birth was amazing with no complications. Just not sure which route I should go. We do live in a rural area so the nearest other options are over an hour away. Any of you ladies have any advice?