Eyebrow guidance please

Ke

[I'm sorry in advance, I just have a lot to say] So over the past couple months, I have started integrating taking off my eyebrow makeup into my nightly routine. Prior to that, I would keep it on for 2-3 days at a time(I only now realize how weird that is) because I couldn't stand my natural eyebrows. Whenever I used to take off my makeup, I would avoid removing my eyebrow makeup and tell myself that it saved me time in the morning(which now I know is bs); I just disliked my natural eyebrows so much that I didn't want to see them. Lately, I have been pretty consistent in taking off ALL of my makeup(including my eyebrows) at night, and being makeup-free at home. At first no one said anything about it, which is exactly what I wanted so I myself could start getting comfortable with them and not have other people's opinions in my head. On days I have been at home all day, recently, my mom and sister have each told me that I look beautiful without makeup. I still haven't been able to leave the house without at least a little eyebrow makeup on, but I honestly feel that I am starting to like them- I still strongly prefer myself with makeup but I am *slowly* getting used to them and accepting them.

I don't believe I'll be able to go completely makeup free (while outside and going about my daily activities) and I will continue to use my usual eyebrow makeup on a daily basis, but I am trying to cut down on how much I use and lessen the color intensity. Even though I am using temporary makeup and I am researching semi-permanent options, I refuse to do any kind of more-than-temporary anything to my eyebrows until I love them. It may take a while, but I am in it for the long run.

This is with and without eyebrow makeup on(normally I make them look less thin).

I am just wondering what you guys use(if anything) on your eyebrows, and if so what. Are there any affordable semi-permanent options I should look into? I mostly want a fuller look near the front of my eyebrows; I like the fullness of the rest of them.

(I'm not actually that pink all the time, it's just the crappy lighting)