I’m looking for some input!

So my husband and I have had a hard time agreeing on names for our little boy. I had initially liked Noah but it’s so dang common and I just remembered I didn’t like someone named Noah so that’s ruined for me 🙄

My husband brought the name Atlas to the table and I didn’t like it at first but it’s started to grow on me over the past few weeks. Right now it’s looking like our top name but I’m still feeling hesitant about it. Maybe because it’s different than the names I had originally liked and I feel like I’ll regret it because it’s not “normal”??? I just need some input. Is it too weird of a name or am I overreacting?

The name would be either

Atlas Orion Herbst

or

Atlas Shepard Herbst