Should I give him a chance?

So there is this boy. And I’m very confused on how I feel. I like him, but I also don’t have all those feelings for him. He’s very sweet and kind and charming. And he isn’t trying to get with me for my body. (I’m so relieved 😅) He keeps asking me to be his girlfriend and I keep telling him I’m not sure with I feel yet. I honestly don’t know if I want to be his girlfriend or not. I really do like him, I just can’t say yes for some reason and I don’t know why. I think I might be scared to get my heart broken again. Please leave some advice in the comments. (Also text me if you want to know more details)