HELP!???!?

okay so I don't know who my baby daddy is. its between two people. when I took my test it was 9 days after the one possible chance and it was taken at 6PM and it came back positive. the other possible chance was weeks before that one. from this info which do you think is more likely to be the Dad??

the first one was a try for the baby so no pulling out or condom

the 10 days before the test he said he pulled out and I think he did