He has 2 baby mamas??

Would you judge/date a guy that has 3 babies on the way, (1 + twins with second mom) both pregnant due in 3 months apart... he's with the first mom, but the second mom he was more like a sperm donor and didn't think she wanted a relationship because it was a hook up/one night stand type of encounter. Does this seem like a turn off or would you still give a chance?