Which one? Photos below of the ones I got!

Question

I got both for my baby shower, and not sure which to keep. Thoughts/ advice on their of these! Especially if you have them! Thanks in advance.

Answer

How long is the return policy? Maybe keep it until your baby comes and you can see which one he/she likes better?

Answer

We have both of these and our daughter loved both. It just depended on her mood. If she was fussy, she preferred the mamaroo. If she was happy, she preferred the Graco. I would say to keep both.

Answer

I have both! Lol I know a little extreme but the mommaroo was given to us for free and the swing was a gift that couldn’t be returned. I honestly can’t pick between the two. They each serve a purpose for our LO. During the day I’ll put him in the Grace swing, like when he’s trying to stay awake. More toward nighttime I put him in the mommaroo because if tends to make him fall asleep. I would say the mommaroo is more soothing for our baby, but the swing has really been handy too.

Answer

We have the graco and love it

Answer

Honestly it's up to your baby, they're so picky. My eldest loves the mamaroo hated the swing. My youngest hated the mamaroo and loved the swing.

Answer

If the return policy allows, I would wait until after baby is born and you can try both out and see. All babies are different, so you really never know.

Answer

Our son loves his swing. Many times his swing is the only place he will sleep. He also just enjoys hanging out in it awake since it’s a nice change in position from his play mats. He looks around or plays with toys while he’s in it. The swing has been a sanity saver for us.

Answer

Mine never cared for the Mamaroo and preferred a more traditional swing. Unfortunately you won’t know for sure until baby comes. I’d keep both, set the one you like better up and if baby likes it then return the other.

Answer

My son loves his mamaroo but HATES and I mean hates my moms graco swing. He will scream bloody murder in it till you pick him up. it really depends on baby and you. If your super active always moving around the graco swing will be best since it has faster motions. If your not as active a mamaroo would be fine.

Answer

We have the 4moms. Our daughter seems to really enjoy it but every baby is different. I suggest reading the reviews on both and see what others like or don’t like.

Which one? Photos below of the ones I got!

Let's Glow!

The Top Baby Tracker App: Embrace New Beginnings with Tender Care

The Top Fertility Tracker App: Your Path to Achieving Pregnancy

The Top Pregnancy App: Nurturing Your Journey to Motherhood

The Top Period Tracker for Empowering Your Menstrual Health Journey