How to clean anal toys? HELP!

Y’all. Okay.

So I have a G-spot vibrator (battery powered) that I like to use on myself, but my boyfriend has a big anal kink and today we decided to use it in his ass. We put a condom over it and I planned on cleaning it REALLY thoroughly and I figured it’d be fine.

But guys. It smells LIKE ASS. And I cannot get the smell OUT! I washed it twice with soap, then twice with the antibacterial/deodorizing toy cleaner I have (the one from Adam and eve), and once more with soap, and it STILL! smells! like! ass!

What do I DO? I don’t want to get rid of the whole toy! But I can’t use it on myself knowing it smells like somebody else’s ass! (Even if I love him! I’m a germaphobe, and if there’s a smell there’s probably germs!) How do I get this smell out?! Please help me!!