Confused?!

I am so confused. I have a boyfriend I’ve been dating for 2 months, I like him soooo much!! But everyone (my family, sister, and sisters bf) is telling me to go for this other guy. I’ve been talking to this other guy for a while. He’s interested in me. I want them both idk what to do?!!!!

Ugh I’m so confused I don’t like disappointing anyone :((((