Hi ladies, I’m looking for some advice 😊

So my boyfriend is turning 26 on Saturday and I still need to figure out what to get him. I’m definitely really overthinking all this lol but I really want to get him something that he’ll like a lot but isn’t like over the top or too little you know? A little background - we’ve been together for a little over 4 months, for Christmas I got him and I tickets to a hockey game cause he’s a fan of that, he also is into video games and super hero stuff and movies but I was thinking of getting like one of those nice shaving kit things or a nice flannel? What do you guys think, any ideas? 😊