Is there something wrong with me?

Whenever I masturbate I do it by clit stimulation and that’s worked for me but the other day somebody said they wanted to finger me (it was my crush, I was screaming inside) and I sort of dodged the subject because I’d never tried it before, so I tried fingering myself. And I’ve tried multiple times, with enough lubrication, I’m sure, because it doesnt hurt but it just doesn’t feel good. I get absolutely nothing from it. I can’t help but think there is something wrong with me because people I know have said that it feels great etc. Is there something wrong with me?