This just happened to me today. I'm going to return it but I was wondering what other people would do because let me tell you...I was torn with doing the right thing. I had 10% of my paycheck going into a BBT account and the remainder going into my usual checking. Well that 10% wasn't meeting the minimum and I didn't use my debit card enough so long story short...the BBT Account closed unexpectedly. I get paid weekly and got paid on 2/28 and then was supposed to yesterday. I told my boss yesterday though that I needed a new direct deposit form because that 10% was going into a closed account. So she said, "Yes we got the notification! We will hand write you a check." So today, she walks in and I'm expecting this paydays pay. Instead, it was this week and last week. She said, "We got the notification two paydays ago." I said nothing because I won't lie...at first it seemed tempting. I wanted to be slick. After all, we were going to be SUPER tight on bills. I eventually returned it and told her that no, I did receive my money on the 28th.

Being completely honest...would you return it? If you were going to be absolutely dirt broke without the double pay and you know for a fact that they wouldnt catch the mistake...what would you do?

PS. They wouldn't have ever caught the mistake.