First toy ever advice

So I had told my boyfriend of almost a year now that I wanted to get a toy for us. He immediately said no, and I was like in my head "we'll see about that" with the intention of getting one anyways and surprising him. Well one day when he was dirty talking to me he said he thought about it and that he wants me to get a toy! So now I need advice for which kind of toy I want, do I want a dildo, a wand, a vibrator, a plug like what? We do do anal and I'm up to those toys. So help ya girl out, please!