Medela or spectra?

Question

Which breast pump do you prefer?  Insurance is covering either one, and I don’t know which to chose!  Thank you!

Answer

I went with the basic spectra (pink/ no battery) and bought a $10 Medela charger on Amazon so I can pump in the car. I’ve heard anecdotally that the spectra pump pumps a little harder than the Medela (so slightly less risk of mastitis and clogged ducts) and the noise is, in my opinion, a little more pleasing. It also looks a bit more modern. Not important at all but a nice bonus because it’s been sitting on my living room coffee table for 3 months!

Answer

I went with the Spectra. 
I’m only 18 weeks pregnant (FTM) but I liked how small and lightweight it is, plus it is very quiet too.

Answer

Spectra s2!

Answer

I've tried both, I own a Spectra 1 & 2. The insurance paid for the s2 and then I found the s1 in a bargain store randomly. I like both of them for different reasons. Its a love/hate relationship though. I exclusively pump so I absolutely need to make sure I can do so if we go out or travel. The s1 having a battery pack is great for that. However, I personally don't think its as strong as the s2. The battery does last for quite a few pumping sessions.

Answer

I have both and like both. The spectra is a little more gentle, but you have to push the buttons which is annoying to me. The medela cycles through letdown cycles pretimed, so you don’t push anything besides start.
The medela in style is also smaller than the spectra and mine came with a bag and all the parts. Spectra needed to buy a bag and the parts are harder to get.

Answer

Spectra

Answer

I have the Spectra S2 and highly recommend it!

Answer

S1 is great! It was nice being able to pump anywhere in the beginning when I was basically exclusively pumping. In general, the spectra is quieter, parts are easier to clean, and you can choose actual pump cycles which the rhythm and pressure change. It's also a closed system and for me, anything that prevents mold is the better option. This is based on my experience with my personal S1 and the medela symphony provided at work.

Medela or spectra?

Let's Glow!

The Top Baby Tracker App: Embrace New Beginnings with Tender Care

The Top Fertility Tracker App: Your Path to Achieving Pregnancy

The Top Pregnancy App: Nurturing Your Journey to Motherhood

The Top Period Tracker for Empowering Your Menstrual Health Journey