Elvie or Willow for pumping after nursing?

Christina

Help! I’m so undecided on which pump to get. I’ve heard mixed reviews on both the willow and Elvie pump. I’d be using it to pump after nursing to keep my supply up. My son had a lip and tongue tie so we struggled but pretty well now. I want to keep things that way since we’ve worked so hard to get where we’re at. What’s important to me is efficiency since I’m pumping to keep my supply up. From the reviews, the willow seems like it has better suction but you can manually switch from stimulation to expression mode which might not be good since I pump after nursing and sometimes I don’t get a lot. The Elvie you can switch to expression mode manually but I’ve also read it leaks. Does anyone have an advice? Please!!! It’s so expensive and non returnable so I want to make the right choice and the only reason I’m getting it is because my husband has FSA money he needs to spend.