Should I just tell the truth?

Hi everyone so last year around March I got out of a 6 yr relationship it was hard. I met let’s say guy #1 and we flirted and talked but never felt like he was genuine, then I met guy #2 and I instantly felt a connection we started talking and then guy #1 was still around here and there he would flirt with me but I always said I was not ready for a relationship. I talked to guy #2 for a while and I started getting confused with who I liked. I kept them both around to see what I wanted. I ended up kissing both guys and was just so confused. I started feeling guilty and asked everyone if I was wrong, but honestly I feel like I love guy #2 a lot more I stopped talking to guy #1 in December and I feel more happier with guy #2 but the topic on guy #1 came up and I never shared anything expect that he was just my friend. Should I tell him everything that happened or not? I always told both of them I’m not ready for a relationship. But now I feel guilty for having 2 guys around. I really like guy #2 I think I want to let him have his chance with me.. guy #1 Doesn’t really talk to me no more.. but he ended up being with one person who I felt was close to me. Idk if I owe guy #2 a truth or explanation but I cut off guy #1 because I like guy #2. What should I do? I feel like if I tell him he’s going to be hurt but I never established that we were a thing I just wasn’t ready and he wanted to wait for me… what should I do ?