Baby name thief

Years ago when I was pregnant with my daughter my husband and I picked the name Ariah & my husband was fighting hard for the middle name Rose (his grandmothers name) during this discussion his mom happened to call us and he told her our baby name and the middle name consideration. After this she announced that his brothers wife was with her and had just told her she was pregnant and due around the same time as me. Fast forward, his brothers wife ends up having her baby 2 weeks before us and his mother proudly sends us a baby photo with the name announcement “Aria Rose” 🫠 My husband has no relationship with his brother at all but I still didn’t want to name our child the same thing so we used another name. Im glad now that I named my daughter something else but I’m still in love with the name Ariah. I recently found out I’m pregnant again and we don’t know the gender yet but if it’s a girl we are strongly considering just naming her that anyways of course with a different middle name. Opinions?