Belly buttons: keep jewelry in, or just re-pierce later?

Erin

Which one usually has better results? I know many of you have had belly piercings and have had at least one pregnancy, and I am just curious as to which approach is more successful for the overall quality of the piercing.

On the one hand, I know an open piercing will stretch. I don't know how well it shrinks back to size.

On the other, scar tissue is unpredictable and piercing through it may result in a less well-placed or aesthetically pleasing piercing.

What did you do? How did it turn out? Would you do it that way again?

Vote below to see results!